Results full CLUST 2015

The official results on all test data from CLUST 2015 are listed on this page.

For detailed results click here.

The CLUST 2015 results, based on the reduced first test set and listed in the MICCAI 2015 proceedings can be found here.

The CLUST 2014 results can be found here.


Results of 2D point-landmark tracking. The results are in millimetres and ranked according to increasing mean tracking error.

Participant
Tracking error [mm]
Submission date
Mean Standard deviation 95th percentile
Liu., et al. 0.69 0.67 1.57 Sep 2019
Shepard A., et al. 0.72 1.25 1.71 Jan 2017
Williamson T., et al. 0.74 1.03 1.85 June 2017
Wang Y., et al. 0.75 0.62 1.65 March 2022
Anonymous* 0.79 0.83 2.33 July 2022
Wu C., et al. 0.80 1.16 2.29 December 2020
Jeungyoon L., et al. 0.85 0.80 2.32 April 2019
anonymous* 0.86 1.60 2.43 November 2020
anonymous* 1.01 1.16 2.21 October 2022
Shen C., et al. 1.11 0.91 2.68 July 2018
Hallack A., et al.# 1.21 3.17 2.82 October 2015
anonymous* 1.29 1.43 3.59 April 2022
Gomariz A., et al.# 1.34 2.57 2.95 October 2018
anonymous* 1.38 3.11 4.25 May 2021
Makhinya M. & Goksel O.# 1.44 2.80 3.62 October 2015
Bharadwaj S., et al. 1.60 3.69 4.21 February 2021
anonymous* 1.89 3.58 10.78 September 2020
anonymous* 2.01 3.11 9.31 Feb 2022
Ihle F. A. 2.48 5.09 15.13 March 2017
anonymous* 2.53 4.39 13.73 October 2021
Kondo S.# 2.91 10.52 5.18 October 2015
Nouri D. & Rothberg A.# 3.35 5.21 14.19 October 2015


Results of 3D point-landmark tracking. The results are in millimetres and ranked according to increasing mean tracking error.

Participant
Tracking error [mm]
Submission date
Mean Standard deviation 95th percentile
anonymous* 1.70 0.98 3.05 Jan 2020
Royer L., et al.# 1.74 0.92 3.65 Oct 2015
Banerjee J., et al.# 1.80 1.64 3.41 Oct 2015
anonymous* 1.82 1.17 3.47 April 2023
anonymous* 2.14 1.16 3.93 Mar 2020
anonymous* 4.53 5.65 11.81 October 2022
anonymous* 4.90 4.96 16.43 October 2021

* Informal submission

# No access to 20% of all data before computation of the tracking results (on-site challenge at MICCAI 2015 CLUST).


ETH Zurich

CVL ETH

ICR

LCSR Johns Hopkins